CPA public practice · Registered tax agent 26267209
Tax

What to Do When You Cannot Pay Your Tax Bill

If you cannot pay your tax bill, lodge it anyway and then set up a payment plan. Lodging and paying are two separate obligations, and the penalties for not lodging are charged on top of the interest on what you owe. Most small businesses with a debt of $200,000 or less can arrange a payment plan themselves through ATO online services without ever speaking to anyone.

That is the short answer. The longer answer matters too, because October is the month this problem lands on a lot of desks. Your September quarter BAS is due 28 October 2026, and if you lodge your own individual return it is due 31 October 2026. Two bills, one month, and often not enough in the bank account to cover either.

What happens if you just do nothing?

Three things start happening, and they stack.

First, the general interest charge begins accruing from the day after the due date. The GIC rate for the October to December 2026 quarter is 11.51% a year, and it compounds daily. That is a higher rate than most business overdrafts, and it keeps running until the debt is cleared.

Second, from 1 July 2025 you can no longer claim a tax deduction for ATO interest charges. Both the general interest charge and the shortfall interest charge are now non-deductible. This is a real change in the maths. A debt sitting at 11.51% used to cost you less after the deduction, and now it costs you the full rate.

Third, if you have not lodged, you cop a failure to lodge on time penalty as well. That penalty is one penalty unit for every 28 days the document is late, or part of 28 days, up to a maximum of five units. A penalty unit is $364 from 1 July 2026. For a small business that is up to $1,820 per outstanding document, on top of the tax and the interest.

The quiet cost is the one nobody puts a number on. An unexplained ATO debt is the single fastest way to lose access to finance, because tax debts over $100,000 that are not being managed can be reported to credit reporting bureaus. Lenders see it.

Quick tip: The ATO treats a business that lodges on time and pays late very differently from one that goes quiet. Lodging on time keeps you in the first category, and that category gets payment plans approved.

Should you lodge your BAS if you cannot pay it?

Yes, every time. This is the single most common and most expensive mistake small business owners make with tax debt.

People hold off lodging because lodging feels like admitting to a bill they cannot pay. The opposite is true. Lodging creates a known, fixed debt that you can then arrange to pay over time. Not lodging creates an unknown debt, adds a separate penalty, and takes away your ability to negotiate.

You also cannot set up a payment plan for a debt that has not been lodged. The ATO needs a figure before it can agree to instalments on that figure. So the order is always lodge first, then arrange the payment. If you are unclear on what your activity statement should include, our guide to what BAS is and whether you need to lodge it walks through it.

If you are already behind on several quarters, that is a bigger job but a solvable one. Getting the overdue statements prepared and lodged is exactly what our catch-up and clean-up service exists for, and the ATO is noticeably more flexible with a business that brings everything up to date at once.

How much does ATO interest actually cost you?

Most people underestimate this, because 11.51% does not sound frightening until you see it compounding daily on a five figure debt over a year or two.

Use the estimator below to see what a payment plan on your debt would look like. It calculates the monthly instalment and the interest you would pay on top.

ATO payment plan estimator





Monthly instalment:

Total interest you will pay:

Total repaid:

Based on the general interest charge rate of 11.51% a year for the October to December 2026 quarter, compounding daily, on a reducing balance. The ATO reviews this rate every quarter, so your actual interest will move with it. This estimate does not include any failure to lodge penalty. ATO interest is not tax deductible for amounts incurred on or after 1 July 2025.

Run $20,000 over 24 months and the interest alone comes to about $2,500. That is the real price of a slow payment plan, and it is the argument for paying it off faster where you can.

How do you set up an ATO payment plan?

For a debt of $200,000 or less you can do it yourself in about 10 minutes, and you do not have to explain yourself to anybody.

If you are a company, trust or partnership

Log in to Online services for business, go to the accounts and payments menu, and choose the payment plan option. The system will offer you a schedule and show the estimated interest. You can adjust the instalment amount and the start date within limits.

If you are a sole trader or individual

Log in to ATO online services through myGov and follow the same path, or use the automated phone service on 13 28 65. The automated line works outside business hours, which is useful if you are dealing with this at 9pm.

If you owe more than $200,000

You need to speak to someone. Call the ATO or have your registered tax agent arrange it for you. Agents can often negotiate terms that the online system will not offer, particularly on longer plans, because they can present the full picture of the business.

Two things to know before you commit. Interest keeps accruing for the whole life of the plan, so a shorter plan is always cheaper. And you must keep lodging and paying everything new that falls due while the plan is running. Missing a new BAS is the fastest way to have a payment plan cancelled, and once cancelled the whole balance becomes payable again.

Can the ATO reduce the interest and penalties?

Sometimes, and it is worth asking. The ATO has the power to remit both the general interest charge and the failure to lodge penalty, but it is a discretion and not a right.

Remission is most likely where something outside your control caused the problem. Serious illness, a natural disaster, a death in the business, a bank or software failure, or a major client collapsing on you are the kinds of circumstances that get looked at. A request supported by dates, documents and a clear explanation does considerably better than a general plea.

Penalty remission is also more likely for a first offence by a business with an otherwise clean compliance record. This is the practical reason to care about your lodgement history even in years where it does not feel urgent. The history is the thing you draw on when you need help.

You can request remission yourself in writing, or ask your agent to do it. Making the request does not pause the debt, so set up the payment plan first and seek remission alongside it, not instead of it.

What if a payment plan is not enough?

If the business cannot service even a 24 month plan, the problem is not the tax bill. The tax bill is the symptom.

Start by working out whether this is a timing problem or a profitability problem. A timing problem means the money is coming but not fast enough, and the fix is in your invoicing and collection. A profitability problem means the money is not coming at all, and no payment plan will solve it.

You need accurate figures to tell the difference, which is where a current set of books stops being an admin task and becomes a decision-making tool. Our BAS lodgement service starts at $99 a quarter and includes the GST review that usually surfaces the real number. If your records are in no state to produce one, read what to do when your books are a complete mess first.

For genuinely unviable situations, the ATO can consider release from certain tax debts on serious hardship grounds, and the Small Business Debt Helpline offers free, independent financial counselling on 1800 413 828. Neither is a first resort, and both are better than waiting.

How do you avoid this happening next quarter?

GST is not your money. That is the whole lesson, and almost every tax debt we see traces back to it.

When a customer pays you $11,000 including GST, $1,000 of that belongs to the ATO and you are holding it for them. If it sits in the one account you pay wages and rent from, it gets spent. Not deliberately, just gradually.

The fix is a second bank account and a standing rule. Every time money comes in, move the GST portion across, and leave it there. Do this and your quarterly BAS stops being a bill and becomes a transfer. Businesses that set this up almost never end up on a payment plan.

The second habit is reconciling monthly rather than scrambling in the last week of the quarter. You find the surprises early, when they are still small, and you know your BAS figure three weeks before it is due. Our pricing is tiered by your annual revenue, starting at $98 a month for businesses turning over under $50,000, so monthly bookkeeping costs less than one penalty unit. We work with clients across the country, from Vermont in Melbourne through to small businesses in Brisbane, entirely through Xero.

Frequently asked questions

Will the ATO take me to court if I cannot pay?

Not as a first step, and almost never for a business that is engaging with them. The ATO escalates to firmer action such as garnishee notices or director penalty notices when a debt is ignored, not when it is being paid down under an arrangement. Setting up a payment plan and keeping to it is what takes legal action off the table.

Does interest keep running while I am on a payment plan?

Yes. The general interest charge accrues for the entire life of the plan at 11.51% a year for the current quarter, compounding daily. This is why the shortest plan you can realistically afford is always the cheapest, and why paying extra when you have a good month genuinely saves money.

Can I claim the ATO interest as a tax deduction?

No, not for interest incurred on or after 1 July 2025. Both the general interest charge and the shortfall interest charge became non-deductible from that date, regardless of which income year the underlying debt relates to. If you have been budgeting on the old deduction, your real cost of carrying ATO debt has gone up.

Is it cheaper to borrow from the bank and pay the ATO out?

Often yes, because business loan interest remains deductible while ATO interest no longer is. A deductible 10% loan can work out cheaper than a non-deductible 11.51% GIC. Run the numbers on your own tax rate before you decide, and be careful not to swap a flexible ATO plan for a loan with tighter covenants.

What happens if I miss a payment on my plan?

One missed payment does not usually cancel the plan automatically, but it does flag your account. Contact the ATO before the payment is due if you know you will miss it, because varying a plan is routine and reinstating a cancelled one is not. If a plan is cancelled the full balance becomes payable immediately.

Should I pay my BAS or my superannuation first if I can only do one?

Superannuation, in almost every case. Unpaid super attracts the superannuation guarantee charge, which is not deductible and can be recovered from directors personally through a director penalty notice. Under Payday Super, which started 1 July 2026, super must reach the employee’s fund within seven business days of payday, so the window for falling behind is much shorter than it used to be.

Share LinkedIn Facebook
Written by
Aazath Asmeer
AffordBooksTax

Need Help With Your Books?

AffordBooksTax handles bookkeeping, BAS, payroll and tax returns for small businesses across Australia. Starting from $98 a month.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Book a call WhatsApp